I haven’t returned to Johny’s Luncheonette since I tried their disappointing Famous Sloppy Johny (grilled chicken, bacon, onions, cheese and coleslaw on a hero). Sounds amazing, but didn’t work for me. It says a lot when you put “Home of the Sloppy Johny” on your awning, so I didn’t expect much from anything else on the menu. I was dead wrong. The Melissa Munchie (Hot Roast Beef, SautÃ©ed Mushrooms, Onion Rings, and Melted Mozzarella on Garlic Bread) is frickin’ awesome. They even threw in a few fries in there. All the ingredients work together and melds into one hell of a trucker-style sandwich.
I feel bad that I wrote off Johny’s after that first sandwich. Now I have to eat my words …and I’d be happy to.
Johnyâ€™s Luncheonette â€“ 124 W. 25th Street (btw 6th & 7th Ave) New York City, NY 10001