Goya Mayo-Ketchup …Instant Fancy Sauce! Jason Lam Aug 18, 2010 product 17 At $3.59, I guess you’re paying for the convenience. 17 Responses toddles Aug 19, 2010 used to buy this mustard/mayo mashup at publix in tallahassee… http://beavertonfoods.com/store/images/honey-mustard-mayo-sq.jpg Reply Jason Lam Aug 20, 2010 mayo goes well with everything Reply Tio Wally Aug 23, 2010 When I was a kid my mom would mix ketchup, mustard and mayo, and claimed it was the same as Jack in the Box’s “Secret Sauce.” I don’t know if it is really the same but I still make it occasionally to dip fish sticks in. A nice addition to it is Sriracha sauce for a little kick. Reply Jason Lam Aug 27, 2010 That’s taking fancy sauce to fancy pants there. Reply Nik Aug 24, 2010 In the UK the ketchup-mayo mix is known as ‘burger sauce’ and is great with chips (fries) or on Turkish kebabs. It is widely available in the south but in the north they prefer gravy with their chips! Reply Jason Lam Aug 27, 2010 oh that’s interesting …with Turkish Kebabs. I don’t think they give us a sauce for that here in NY. Reply Nick Aug 26, 2010 I’ve been mixing mayo and ketchup since I was a little kid and I always dreamed about being able to buy it in a bottle perfectly pre-mixed. I even though of a name for it. “Metchup.” Reply Christie May 24, 2011 Where did you see it in NYC! We need to buy this fancy sauce! It’s not in my Goya sections anywhere that I’ve seen yet!! Reply Jason Lam May 24, 2011 This was at my local C-Town (Graham stop on the L train – Williamsburg, Brooklyn). But I haven’t seen it there since. I could use some right now for my boca chicken nuggets. Reply Patrick Jul 10, 2011 In my family, we’ve been mixing mayo and ketchup (with a dash of paprika and parsley) for years each time we eat chinese fondue. Sooo yummy! Reply Jason Lam Jul 11, 2011 I gotta try that …paprika and parsley. Makes a ton of sense. Thanks for the tip! Reply Chris Dec 1, 2011 In Utah and Idaho this is called “Fry Sauce” it usually has a little bit of Worcestershire sauce mixed with the mayo and ketchup. So if you go to Utah just ask for Fry sauce when you get a burger and fries at most of the local burger joints. Reply Jason Lam Dec 2, 2011 I gotta try adding Worcestershire sauce. Thanks! Reply Lori Oct 14, 2012 I won’t give away my exact recipe due to a pending patent on it but I mix ketchup, mustard, and mayo. I’ve always done this and use it as a dip for fries and as a burger sauce. The secret to the sauce is using the right base ingredients. If you use say the wrong brands it won’t have that creamy stick to your ribs consistency. The flavor profile will also be off. It has taken me years to perfect but it’s so good I have ate it by itself. Hope to have it on store shelves soon. Reply Jason Lam Oct 16, 2012 That’s funny. My roommate just talked about bottling his own fancy sauce, but I’m sure that’ll never happen. More Fancy Sauces need to be on the market for sure. You should make it happen! Reply jerry turienzo Nov 12, 2012 no comment for now Reply Moises Jan 5, 2013 I am debating and telling folks this is not Russian dressing! Where’s the chives, pimientos and horseradish?! Thank you very much. I grew up putting Mayo Ketchup on my foods from time to time! Reply Leave a Reply to jerry turienzo Cancel Reply Your email address will not be published.CommentName Email Website Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.